Red Sea Crisis insurance withdrawals – fact or fiction?

Red Sea Crisis insurance withdrawals – fact or fiction?

In addition to fast-rising ocean freight rates and extended transit times, as the container shipping lines divert around Africa, shippers have been struggling to understand what (if any) insurance is in place, with insurance companies massively increasing war risk premiums and no longer willing to cover Red Sea voyages. 

In this constantly shifting situation it is critical that shippers understand what insurance covers are being referred to in current news report and what this means for their cargo.

As with all markets impacted by the Houthi rebel attacks the insurance market is changing almost daily with rumours and facts being thrown around in equal measure.

Insurance has been impacted like all areas of the supply chain, with costs increasing as the risk increases. This is true of hull insurances (to protect the vessel), as it is with the general war risk cover applied to marine cargo policies.

For those unfamiliar with insurance and when and how they apply, goods in transit insurance covers cargo against loss or damage whilst being transported from one place to another, or being stored during a journey.

If you are shipping goods by sea for example, you would take out marine cargo insurance which can be written on an annual basis, or purchased for individual shipments.

NOTE – Marine insurance is not included within the freight charges and agreements. 

For marine cargo insurance to be in place, with cover applicable to your goods, you need to specifically request insurance with a separate premium being payable.

Marine cargo insurance is different to marine hull insurance, with the latter covering the cost of repairs or replacement of the vessel, in the event of any loss and/or damage.

Hull insurance is typically purchased by ship owners, boat owners and charterers to protect against a range of risks associated with owning and operating vessels.

War risk cover, which provides insurance on losses resulting from events such as war, invasions, strikes and terrorism can be included within these policies or be purchased separately from specialist markets.

Insurers across the markets all take individual approaches to what cover they are applying, or withdrawing as the case may be.

Ships and vessel owners are being hit with high insurance premiums with reports that some insurers are refusing to cover vessels against war risk in the key commercial shipping corridor through the Red Sea.

For Lloyds insurers, their Joint War Committee has widened the areas in the Red Sea that are categorised as “high risk”, with war risk insurance premiums for vessels intending to sail through such areas rising from 0.07 to 0.7% – that’s a 900% increase in a month.

With the potential removal of some covers, including war risk cover, this can dictate the need for specific routes on the movement of goods. Whilst it may be reasonable for ship owners to request that routes through the Rea Sea be avoided, on a commercial basis, due to safety concerns. As a shipper you need to make sure that your insurers are comfortable with the changes and that the level of risk and cover you have is still sufficient to protect your cargoes.

Shipping around the coast of Africa also has its own complications, with the return of piracy off the coast of Somalia.

If you do find your insurer or insurance team changing or amending your policy and you need some advice in understanding what options are open to you, please do not hesitate to EMAIL our Chief Finance Officer Laurence Burford who will be happy to assist where possible.

There may be alternative insurance products that could protect your business more effectively in this ever changing world, but their merits need to be reviewed on a case by case basis with varying factors impacting cost and availability.

It is important to note that the surcharges that are raised by shipping lines during a time of war or crisis, despite how they may be worded, do not cover risks for the value of cargo moved on vessels.

These surcharges are designed solely to recoup additional costs incurred by the ship’s owner and/or operator, including higher insurance premiums for potential damage or destruction of a ship, and not for the container contents stowed on-board.

If you have any questions or concerns about the insurance related to the Suez situation, or would like to discuss its wider implications please EMAIL our Chief Finance Officer Laurence Burford.

Should you wish to obtain a quote on a particular insurance product please provide as much information as possible where known including but not limited to cargo type, cargo value, route, vessel details and such.

General Red Sea Update

General Red Sea Update

The US and UK carried out eight strikes on Houthi targets in Yemen on Monday, as the Iran-aligned armed group continues to target commercial shipping in the Red Sea, with no sign that the conflict will de-escalate anytime soon.

While many hoped that the situation in the Red Sea might be a short-lived crisis, it is edging closer to the challenges that global supply chains faced during the COVID-19 pandemic. 

The ripple effects caused by the necessity of re-routing around 90% of all container ships from Asia around the Cape of Good Hope are immense. Analyst Sea-Intelligence are concluding that the vessel capacity drop is the second largest after the ‘Ever Given’ got stuck in the Suez Canal for six days during March 2021. 

With 10+ days added to the normal transit the drop in available capacity has sent freight rates rocketing, with container equipment challenges growing and expected to become far more difficult in the run up to the Chinese lunar new year. 

CMA CGM, the world’s third-largest carrier, announced an empty container imbalance surcharge of $100 per unit on top of similar equipment surcharges out of Turkey to the Mediterranean and North Africa announced last week.

There is one significant difference between now and the Ever Given situation and the pandemic, which is demand is lower and the shipping lines have injected significant capacity to maintain services. 

The Ever Given disruption occurred during a period of scarce capacity and historic peak demand, which was why rates skyrocketed and while we aren’t currently at those highs, the recent rate surge is noticeable in the short term.

The current delays and projected longer transit times are already impacting manufacturers across the globe, with many forced to halt production due to shipment delays, while many retailers have warned of product delays and cost increases. 

The next two-to-three weeks could be interesting, with bunched vessels arriving at the main ports, potentially triggering port delays driver shortages and cargo build-ups at warehouses.

The window for booking air freight ahead of Chinese New Year is closing and vessels are quickly filling, which is why we would urge you for your shipping deadlines, so that we can book your space and services at the best possible rates. 

Sharing forecasts for your forthcoming movements is an essential tool in managing your freight and expectations, and reserving the equipment you need, when you need it. 

If you have any questions or concerns about the impact of the Suez situation on your Asia supply chain, or would like to discuss its wider implications, please EMAIL our Chief Commercial Officer, Andy Smith.

Insurers withdraw war risk cover

Insurers withdraw war risk cover

Since December 2023, nearly 30 commercial vessels transiting the Red Sea have faced missile strikes or near misses from the Yemen-based Houthis, including container ships owned by Maersk, MSC and CMA CGM.

As of last week, 550 container ships have been diverted away from the Suez Canal or are planning to reroute around the south of Africa via the Cape of Good Hope to avoid Red Sea attacks.

Some ships are still travelling through the Suez Canal. Beijing has been neutral on the Houthi attacks but the disruption has raised freight rates, while France’s CMA CGM is still sending some ships through the canal when they can get French warship escorts.

Last week Lloyd’s and London market marine insurers confirmed that they are continuing to maintain cover for cargo and ships transiting the Red Sea despite increasing tensions, but some ship insurers are starting to avoid covering commercial ships against war risks when they navigate the southern Red Sea.

War-risk insurance premiums have already climbed from 0.75-1% of the vessel’s value, which means, shipowners will now have to pay $millions for war-risk insurance cover, depending on vessel age, size and type, with underwriters seeking exclusions for vessels with links to the UK, US and Israel, when issuing cover for ships transiting the Red Sea.

In addition to the soaring annual premium, shipowners will also have to pay an additional premium if they want to transit via the Red Sea. It is because several Protection and Indemnity (P&I) clubs have expanded their additional premium zones across the Indian Ocean, Gulf of Aden and Southern Red Sea.

We have seen evidence however, that some insurers won’t cover anything from a war risk perspective around the Horn of Africa and the Red Sea, which means even more commercial shipping companies will be rerouting through The Cape of Good Hope in the near future.

The massive boost to insurance rates is likely to make the Cape of Good Hope routing more cost effective for carriers relative to the Suez Canal, even with the higher fuel costs.

Metro recommends All Risk marine insurance to protect you against all loss of cargo, to the full value of the goods.

Carriers and other supply chain participants operate under conditions that limit their liability and may even require you to compensate them, in certain circumstances, which means that any compensation you receive is likely to be considerably lower than your actual loss.

Metro work with selected partners to offer All Risk marine insurance cover that protects your cargo during every stage of transportation and storage, on a per shipment or annual cover basis.

Please contact your Metro Account Manager for further information.

Red Sea Crisis; Situation Report, Wednesday 17th Jan

Red Sea Crisis; Situation Report, Wednesday 17th Jan

Despite coalition military action, Houthi rebels continue to attack commercial shipping and with container shipping line’ schedules showing Cape of Good Hope routing for vessels into early February and beyond, it is clear that they do not expect short-term access through the Suez Canal and Red Sea route.

There have been very few attacks directed at container vessels over the last seven days, so gladly we have little to report on specific incidents. 

However, the vast majority of container vessels are no longer transiting the Red Sea, so in essence there are far fewer potential targets to attack, which has resulted in bulk vessels, tanker and naval vessels being the focus of recent missile and drone launches. 

The situation continues to develop every day and we will continue to advise and update, but with the amount of container traffic now avoiding the area of conflict we do not anticipate much direct information on missile strikes against container vessels.

The shipping lines continue to announce surcharges for cargo on vessels affected by the diversion from Suez, as well as those that aren’t, and while the SCFI spot rate index from Asia to N.Europe is up over 200%, its rate of growth has slowed. 

In addition, we have now been notified of at least four RoRo carriers rerouting vessels away from the Red Sea and also surcharges are being announced by this mode of ocean freight over recent days, that we will continue to share with our clients utilising these vessels. 

The challenges continue to expand across global shipping in all formats.

Equipment

Re-routing container ships around the Cape of Good Hope instantly delayed afloat shipments to Europe and the US East Coast by 5-14 days. And this is without considering the ‘pause’ where vessels were held or diverted, which could have added another 15 days to the transit on top of the longer journey times.

With almost 400K TEU returning to the Far East every week, the lost two weeks sailing round-Africa means that around 800K TEU will not now arrive in time for the Chinese New Year peak, which will create shortages in key locations. 

Time-critical shipments

Air freight rates out of Asia are likely to surge in the coming weeks as European importers seek an alternative option to avoid ocean equipment shortages, delays in transit, and schedule disruptions brought on by the Red Sea shipping crisis. 

We anticipate that time-critical modes will begin to have their own challenges with demand of converted distressed ocean freight movements, as shippers need to repair low inventory levels to maintain sales and/or production schedules. 

It has already been widely publicised that several automotive OEM’s will halt production due to a lack of components – including Tesla, Suzuki and Volvo at several of their European plants.

UK/European and Global port congestion

Despite the fears of delayed vessels arriving en-masse, leading to congestion, the feedback we are getting from the container ports, including Felixstowe, Southampton and London Gateway, is largely positive. 

With vessels held in the Red Sea area and then diverted around the Cape of Good Hope (COGH) there has been a two-week service slide, which does mean delays to vessel arrivals, but a fairly consistent schedule of ships (though 10 to 14 days behind pro forma arrival). 

Carriers are booking their berth slots +10 days later than the pre-diversion estimate on an ongoing basis and the ports are not anticipating any immediate berth congestion, with vessels due early January now arriving next week. Followed by vessels 10+ days off original schedules, on an ongoing basis.

This means a low impact on operations, without too many ships arriving at the same time and being held out due to berth availability, though some bunching is expected towards the end of January. 

The primary UK container ports can comfortably handle two or more Ultra Large vessels at the same time and in most cases the container stacks are relatively light with low dwell times, which means they have the space to handle any influx of containers.

UK Haulage remains quiet and while there will be increased pressure when vessels arrive, the level of business arriving is not expected to challenge, other than urgent cargo and completing moves within the restricted free-time periods.

To mitigate any impact the shipping lines will be working with port operations to create a plan to get their vessels through in good time and will adjust earlier calls accordingly.

This model and planning seems to be emulated throughout the global ports infrastructure and currently most of the international port operators and local organisations seem confident they will be able to cope with and accommodate the disrupted schedules and arrivals and departures of vessels. 

We will discover if this optimism comes to fruition over coming weeks in Europe, Asia and The Americas and we continue to monitor the situation on an end to end basis. History would suggest the sailing will not be quite as smooth as predicted. We will keep you advised of developments.

Short-term outlook

For Asia/Europe services the 11 week sailing rotations are becoming 13/14/15 week rotations due to an additional 10 days Westbound and again on the Eastbound leg, which carriers are mitigating by introducing additional tonnage, to maintain weekly calls.  

Any concern is more linked to the return of the Suez transit, as subject to timing the ports foresee the potential for berthing pinch points in Europe and/or the Far East as the vessels diverting back clash with those routed via Africa. However, any impact will be subject to timing, given the Chinese New Year period is also ahead.

In summary, cargo/vessels will arrive later than scheduled, but now the Cape diversion is becoming normal and UK ports are not expecting any immediate concerns until the return to Suez transit commences. 

Also with other conflict beginning to break out on a wider regional level with Iran launching attacks on Iraqi, Pakistani and Syrian militant group targets over recent days, along with the continuing Israel/ Gaza conflict we will ensure we advise on any wider impact on global logistics and supply chain disruption outside of the direct container vessel attacks. 

Unfortunately this looks likely to escalate further.

Other trade lanes and impact/challenges that are developing around the world

As we have been advising and explaining since the outset of the current crisis in the Middle East, this will evolve into issues occurring in markets not directly related to the transit of the Red Sea. 

We are now beginning to see carriers implementing various unconditional surcharges on other routes such as the transAtlantic trade, Australasia from Asia, transPacific and other more niche markets. 

The carries advise that equipment is being redirected back to Asia from these lanes so there is an issue with container availability, vessels are being ‘cascaded’ onto longer transit routes resulting in lower supply of container ships on unrelated trades and a plethora of other reasons resulting in higher operating costs and disfunction. 

We will advise and update on all lanes that have been or will be affected as we are notified. We obviously try to avoid any additional costs and negotiate, reason and reject all increases using logic and relationship management where we can – however this is not always successful. 

We will ensure that advice is delivered constantly to you on this aspect of the services and we are conscious of the critical nature of price fluctuations.

What can you do to mitigate impact and assist us in delivering to deadlines?

The more visibility that we have of your urgent shipments and the understanding of priority movements that have a deadline, the better we can provide a tailored solution and outcome to ensuring that expectations are met. 

We encourage, request and will assist in plotting forecasts for you ideally with as much foresight and planning as possible. In addition we expect to see air freight and sea/ air become much more prevalent, and in fact we already have seen a 50% increase in volumes by these modes, over coming weeks. 

If you have urgent shipments we can work on all options driven by the timelines and ensure that the lowest cost alternative solution is used and that we place extra scrutiny and milestone management on each movement. 

Please do share your forecasts and we are keen to discuss the specific plan for all shipments over the next month and beyond to ensure we have one view and full understanding of everything that is currently or planned to enter the supply chain for you.

The window for booking air freight ahead of Chinese New Year is closing over the next couple of weeks and we expect air cargo rates to increase out of China, which is why we would urge you to contact us without delay, so that we can book your aircraft space and services at the best possible rates for your time-critical cargo. 

Please do provide forecasts for all of your known logistics movements over coming weeks and months – this is an essential tool for us to manage your freight and your expectations.

An additional 10 days ocean freight transit is manageable for most shippers, but we are already getting reports of container shortages and it is essential that you share your shipping forecasts, so that we can reserve the equipment you need, when you need it. 

If you have any questions or concerns about the impact of the Suez situation on your Asia supply chain, or would like to discuss its wider implications, please EMAIL our Chief Commercial Officer, Andy Smith.